Extracting legal causation from international investment law
| Published: | Heidelberg : Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law, 2020 |
|---|---|
| Persons: | |
| Format: | Book / E-Book |
| Language: | English |
| Series: | MPIL research paper series
; no. 2020, 36 |
| Physical description: | 1 Online-Ressource (15 Seiten) |
| Classification - More hits on the same topic: | VR: XV Dc = Völkerrecht: Finanzrecht. Anleihe.: |
| record_format |
marc |
|---|---|
| fullrecord |
02408nmm 2200289 ub4500001001200000003002700012008003900039007002400078100003800102245008100140260010700221300003500328520140400363041001901767993000901786993001001795993000801805997001101813490004501824830001601869856014201885084001402027998001402041998002602055998001402081696002302095 VR001092789 VRH01000000000000001074181 s2020 ||| eng cr||||||||||||||||||||| 1 aJarrett, Martin <<[VerfasserIn]>> 00 aExtracting legal causation from international investment law cMartin Jarrett aHeidelberg bMax Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law c[08 Oct 2020], 2020 a1 Online-Ressource (15 Seiten) aWhenever the question of state responsibility in investor-state arbitration arises, the following causal question must be analysed: has the state conduct caused the investors investment loss? To answer this question, arbitral tribunals apply the approach advocated for by the International Law Commission, which in turn is the approached used by domestic courts. This is a two-tiered approach where the factual causality and legal causality of the state conduct is tested. This contribution argues that adopting this approach into the jurisprudence of international investment law was an error. Specifically, the process of testing for legal causation has no place in international investment law and should be extracted from it. Not only are attempts by arbitral tribunals to test for legal causality likely to lead to low-quality legal reasoning, which can only adversely impact the legitimacy of the international adjudication of investor-state disputes, the reasons for undertaking this process in domestic tortious disputes are not applicable to investor-state disputes. This extraction of legal causation will not lead to indeterminate state liability towards investors. For a number of reasons, the problem of infinite causality in legal disputes is more theoretical than real. With this extraction, a bespoke approach to analysing causal questions in international investment law is produced 07 aeng 2ISO 639-2 a2101 aebook apdf aonline 0 aMPIL research paper series vno. 2020, 36 0 aVR001016025 a uhttps://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3705322 qapplication/pdf xVerlag 3Volltext zKostenfrei zugänglich ohne Registrierung aVR: XV Dc aVR: XV Dc aFinanzrecht. Anleihe. aVR: XV Dc aJarrett, Martin A. |
| spelling |
Jarrett, Martin <<[VerfasserIn]>> Extracting legal causation from international investment law Martin Jarrett Heidelberg Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law 08 Oct 2020], 2020 1 Online-Ressource (15 Seiten) Whenever the question of state responsibility in investor-state arbitration arises, the following causal question must be analysed: has the state conduct caused the investors investment loss? To answer this question, arbitral tribunals apply the approach advocated for by the International Law Commission, which in turn is the approached used by domestic courts. This is a two-tiered approach where the factual causality and legal causality of the state conduct is tested. This contribution argues that adopting this approach into the jurisprudence of international investment law was an error. Specifically, the process of testing for legal causation has no place in international investment law and should be extracted from it. Not only are attempts by arbitral tribunals to test for legal causality likely to lead to low-quality legal reasoning, which can only adversely impact the legitimacy of the international adjudication of investor-state disputes, the reasons for undertaking this process in domestic tortious disp MPIL research paper series no. 2020, 36 VR001016025 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3705322 Verlag Volltext Kostenfrei zugänglich ohne Registrierung Jarrett, Martin A. |
| language |
English |
| format |
0/Buch/ 1/Buch/E-Buch/ |
| author |
Jarrett, Martin <<[VerfasserIn]>> |
| spellingShingle |
Jarrett, Martin <<[VerfasserIn]>> Extracting legal causation from international investment law MPIL research paper series VR001016025 |
| author_facet |
Jarrett, Martin <<[VerfasserIn]>> Jarrett, Martin <<[VerfasserIn]>> |
| author_role |
- |
| author_sort |
Jarrett, Martin <<[VerfasserIn]>> |
| author2 |
Jarrett, Martin <<[VerfasserIn]>> |
| author2_role |
- |
| title |
Extracting legal causation from international investment law |
| title_short |
Extracting legal causation from international investment law |
| title_full |
Extracting legal causation from international investment law Martin Jarrett |
| title_fullStr |
Extracting legal causation from international investment law Martin Jarrett |
| title_full_unstemmed |
Extracting legal causation from international investment law Martin Jarrett |
| title_sort |
extracting legal causation from international investment law martin jarrett |
| series |
MPIL research paper series VR001016025 |
| publisher |
Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law |
| publishDate |
2020 |
| physical |
1 Online-Ressource (15 Seiten) |
| callnumber-raw |
VR: XV DC |
| callnumber-search |
VR: XV DC |
| callnumber-sort |
VR |
| url |
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3705322 |
| illustrated |
Not Illustrated |
| institution |
Local holdings |
| institution_hierarchy |
0/Local holdings/ |
| system_id |
001074181 |
| online |
true |
| dedup_id_str |
JarrettMartinVerfasserInExtractinglegalcausationfrominternationalinvestmentlawMaxPlanckInstituteforComparativePublicLawandInternationalLaw |
| local_classification |
VR: XV Dc |
| hierarchy_parent_id |
001016025 |
| id |
001092789 |
| work_keys_str_mv |
AT jarrettmartinverfasserin extractinglegalcausationfrominternationalinvestmentlaw |
| first_indexed |
2024-05-05T23:44:15Z |
| last_indexed |
2024-05-05T23:44:15Z |
| _version_ |
1800640418738601984 |