Does Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad? : The UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing?

Much has been written on the UKs presumption to derogate from the ECHR in military operations abroad. Unfortunately, the inquiry of the Joint Committee on Human Rights on the proposed derogation launched end of 2016 had to close due to general elections and was regrettably not reopened since. Thus,... Full description

Full text

Bibliographic Details
Published:	Heidelberg : Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law, 2019
Persons:	Spieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>> -
Format:	Book / E-Book
Language:	English
Series:	MPIL research paper series ; no. 2019, 02
Physical description:	1 Online-Ressource (16 Seiten)
Item Description:	Gesehen am 25.02.2019
Classification - More hits on the same topic:	VR: XV Fed = Völkerrecht: Europarat: Europäische Menschenrechts-Konvention. Gerichtshof & Kommission. Europäische Sozialcharta:

record_format	marc
fullrecord	02434nmm 2200301 ub4500001001200000003002700012008003900039007002400078100004600102245016600148260010700314300003500421520126000456041001901716993000901735993000801744993001001752997001101762490004501773830001601818500002601834856009901860084001501959998001501974998010701989998001502096696002102111VR001052072VRH01000000000000001033521 s2019 \|\|\| engcr\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|1 aSpieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>>00aDoes Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad?bThe UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing?cLuke Dimitrios Spieker aHeidelbergbMax Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Lawc[10 Jan 2019], 2019 a1 Online-Ressource (16 Seiten) aMuch has been written on the UKs presumption to derogate from the ECHR in military operations abroad. Unfortunately, the inquiry of the Joint Committee on Human Rights on the proposed derogation launched end of 2016 had to close due to general elections and was regrettably not reopened since. Thus, the presumption to derogate still lacks a final assessment. Although the Committee received submission from leading scholars in the field, the implications of the ECtHRs judgement in Hassan were not at the heart of the discussion. Therefore, this contribution will put the spotlight on this seminal decision and argue that it effectively deprives Art. 15 of any purpose in deployed operations. The ECtHR seems to have developed a new standard the standard of arbitrariness in case of genuine norm conflicts between the ECHR and other international regimes, allowing to lower the ECHRs standard of protection to a mere minimum. This means: the UKs presumption to derogate will have practically no impact. Thus, much ado about nothing? Not quite. Hassan did not concern non-international armed conflicts. Although I argue that it is possible to transfer the verdict to these types of conflicts, it remains to be seen how the ECtHR will decide in this matter07aeng2ISO 639-2 a1902 apdf aebook aonline0 aMPIL research paper seriesvno. 2019, 02 0aVR001016025 aGesehen am 25.02.2019a qpdfuhttps://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3313658xVerlagzKostenfrei3Volltext aVR: XV Fed aVR: XV Fed aEuroparat: Europäische Menschenrechts-Konvention. Gerichtshof & Kommission. Europäische Sozialcharta aVR: XV Fed aSpieker, Dimitri
spelling	Spieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>> Does Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad? The UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing? Luke Dimitrios Spieker Heidelberg Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law 10 Jan 2019], 2019 1 Online-Ressource (16 Seiten) Much has been written on the UKs presumption to derogate from the ECHR in military operations abroad. Unfortunately, the inquiry of the Joint Committee on Human Rights on the proposed derogation launched end of 2016 had to close due to general elections and was regrettably not reopened since. Thus, the presumption to derogate still lacks a final assessment. Although the Committee received submission from leading scholars in the field, the implications of the ECtHRs judgement in Hassan were not at the heart of the discussion. Therefore, this contribution will put the spotlight on this seminal decision and argue that it effectively deprives Art. 15 of any purpose in deployed operations. The ECtHR seems to have developed a new standard the standard of arbitrariness in case of genuine norm conflicts between the ECHR and other international regimes, allowing to lower the ECHRs standard of protection to a mere minimum. This means: the UKs presumption to derogate will have practically no impact. Thus, much ado about MPIL research paper series no. 2019, 02 VR001016025 Gesehen am 25.02.2019 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3313658 Verlag Kostenfrei Volltext Spieker, Dimitri
language	English
format	0/Buch/ 1/Buch/E-Buch/
author	Spieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>>
spellingShingle	Spieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>> Does Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad? : The UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing? MPIL research paper series VR001016025
author_facet	Spieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>> Spieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>>
author_role	-
author_sort	Spieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>>
author2	Spieker, Luke Dimitrios <<[VerfasserIn]>>
author2_role	-
title	Does Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad? : The UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing?
title_sub	The UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing?
title_short	Does Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad?
title_full	Does Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad? The UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing? Luke Dimitrios Spieker
title_fullStr	Does Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad? The UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing? Luke Dimitrios Spieker
title_full_unstemmed	Does Article 15 ECHR still matter in military operations abroad? The UK government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing? Luke Dimitrios Spieker
title_sort	does article 15 echr still matter in military operations abroad? : the uk government's 'presumption to derogate' - much ado about nothing? luke dimitrios spieker
series	MPIL research paper series VR001016025
publisher	Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law
publishDate	2019
physical	1 Online-Ressource (16 Seiten)
callnumber-raw	VR: XV FED
callnumber-search	VR: XV FED
callnumber-sort	VR
url	https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3313658
illustrated	Not Illustrated
institution	Local holdings
institution_hierarchy	0/Local holdings/
system_id	001033521
online	true
dedup_id_str	SpiekerLukeDimitriosVerfasserInDoesArticle15ECHRstillmatterinmilitaryoperationsabroadMaxPlanckInstituteforComparativePublicLawandInternationalLaw
local_classification	VR: XV Fed
hierarchy_parent_id	001016025
id	001052072
work_keys_str_mv	AT spiekerlukedimitriosverfasserin doesarticle15echrstillmatterinmilitaryoperationsabroadtheukgovernmentspresumptiontoderogatemuchadoaboutnothing
first_indexed	2024-05-05T23:43:26Z
last_indexed	2024-05-05T23:43:26Z
_version_	1800640356473110528